Dear Experts,
We had a case similar to this. when we were discussing, we had received different opinion from different people. Just need expert opinion to come into conclusion.
Letter of credit states ''certificate to be presented confirming..................... by the shipping company''
Bill of lading signed by
ABC company Ltd
XXXXXXXXXX
Signed as agent for XYZ carrier,
Can the bill of lading signed by below mentioned
case 1. HMN as carrier (Nowhere related to the bill of lading)
case 2. RMP as agent for the carrier HMN(Nowhere related to the bill of lading)
case 3. WLP as agent for the carrier XYZ carrier.(carrier related to the bill of lading)
or certificate can be accepable if only stating ''shipping company ''' under the said parties without identifying their capacities.
ISBP:
“shipping company” as issuer relating to a transport document : carrier; master or,
when a charter party bill of lading is presented, the master, owner or charterer, or any
entity identified as an agent of any one of the aforementioned, regardless of whether it
issued or signed the presented transport document.
Who Can Sign A Shipping Company Certificate
-
- Posts: 727
- Joined: Sat Oct 15, 2011 12:27 pm
- First Name: Dinesh Kumar
- Last Name: ...
- Organization: Chrome
- Filter: Two Plus Two =: 4
- Location: PU
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 10:52 pm
- First Name: Chan
- Last Name: Ricky
- Organization: bank
- Filter: Two Plus Two =: 4
- Location: HONG KONG
ICC opinion TA670
ICC opinion TA670 would give a clue.
When read with ICC opinion TA670, only the vessel certificate issued by the carrier indicated on the bill of lading or an agent signing on their behalf would comply.
The requirement of ISBP 745 A19 (f) would include carrier (as indicated in the subject transport document) and its agent (regardless of whether it issued or signed the presented transport document or not)
When read with ICC opinion TA670, only the vessel certificate issued by the carrier indicated on the bill of lading or an agent signing on their behalf would comply.
The requirement of ISBP 745 A19 (f) would include carrier (as indicated in the subject transport document) and its agent (regardless of whether it issued or signed the presented transport document or not)
-
- Posts: 727
- Joined: Sat Oct 15, 2011 12:27 pm
- First Name: Dinesh Kumar
- Last Name: ...
- Organization: Chrome
- Filter: Two Plus Two =: 4
- Location: PU
Shipping company
Dear Ricky918,
So i could say
case 1. HMN as carrier (Nowhere related to the bill of lading)-Discrepant
case 2. RMP as agent for the carrier HMN(Nowhere related to the bill of lading)-Discrepant
case 3. WLP as agent for the carrier XYZ carrier.(carrier related to the bill of lading)-No discrepancy. As the carrier is the same as the bill of lading.
What about the parties signing as shipping company without mentioning their capacity/ parties nowhere related to the bill of lading.
Thanks &Regards
Dinesh
So i could say
case 1. HMN as carrier (Nowhere related to the bill of lading)-Discrepant
case 2. RMP as agent for the carrier HMN(Nowhere related to the bill of lading)-Discrepant
case 3. WLP as agent for the carrier XYZ carrier.(carrier related to the bill of lading)-No discrepancy. As the carrier is the same as the bill of lading.
What about the parties signing as shipping company without mentioning their capacity/ parties nowhere related to the bill of lading.
Thanks &Regards
Dinesh
-
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 10:52 pm
- First Name: Chan
- Last Name: Ricky
- Organization: bank
- Filter: Two Plus Two =: 4
- Location: HONG KONG
Comment by Gary collyer on TA670
Hi pal,
As commented by Gary collyer on TA670, the document could be issued on the letterhead of the carrier; the agent that signed the bill of lading, or another agent of the shipping line that so declares that capacity in the certificate.
The vessel certificate should be issued by the carrier indicated on the bill of lading or an agent on its behalf.
Best Regards
Ricky
As commented by Gary collyer on TA670, the document could be issued on the letterhead of the carrier; the agent that signed the bill of lading, or another agent of the shipping line that so declares that capacity in the certificate.
The vessel certificate should be issued by the carrier indicated on the bill of lading or an agent on its behalf.
Best Regards
Ricky